Paper Reviewer
Referee-side skill for Nature Portfolio manuscripts: write a referee report, inventory...
Install
npx skills add Boom5426/Nature-Paper-Skills --skill paper-reviewer -g -a claude-code -y- Repository
- Boom5426/Nature-Paper-Skills646
- Category
- Testing
- Updated
- 22d ago
- License
- MIT
- Context cost
- Mediumabout 3,000 tokens
- Runs scripts
- Yes, review before use
What it does
Referee-side skill for Nature Portfolio manuscripts: write a referee report, inventory every ask and sub-ask in received comments, grade drafted replies, and test reply readability. Check methodology, statistics, reporting, reproducibility and data/code availability. Preserve referee wording, numbering and order; require one reply per ask with a direct opening answer and a manuscript location or explicit no-change rationale. Use for review this manuscript, what will reviewers attack, turn comments into a checklist, answer each comment, did I miss a point, would this reply satisfy the reviewer, 审稿、写审稿意见、模拟审稿、拆解审稿意见、逐个回复、逐条对照、有没有漏回、审稿人会不会接受、以审稿人视角检查回复、回复够不够直白. Use rebuttal-response to choose response stances, calibrate claims and assemble or audit the whole letter.
Referee Reports and the Replies That Answer Them
Two jobs, one standpoint. Writing a referee report and answering one are the same competence seen from two sides: you can only prove you answered a question if you can reconstruct the question that was asked.
Pick the mode before starting.
| Mode | Input | Output |
|---|---|---|
report | a manuscript | a referee report, or a prediction of what referees will attack |
inventory | a referee report | every ask and sub-ask, in the referee's own words and order |
reply | a report plus a manuscript | one reply per ask, plus the coverage audit |
grade | a drafted reply | what an impatient referee would send back |
The contract
A referee report is a list of questions. A reply is a list of answers. The job is to make the two lists line up so exactly that a referee can verify it by scrolling their own report alongside your letter.
Same count. Same identifiers. Same order. Same words. Depth matched to weight.
The alignment has to be visible on the page, not asserted in a summary. Three consequences, and every rule in this skill follows from them:
