Review Paper
Comprehensive manuscript review with three modes: single-pass (default), --adversarial...
Install
npx skills add pedrohcgs/claude-code-my-workflow --skill review-paper -g -a claude-code -y- Repository
- pedrohcgs/claude-code-my-workflow1.7k
- Category
- Testing
- Updated
- 1mo ago
- License
- MIT
- Context cost
- Mediumabout 3,000 tokens
- Runs scripts
- No, instructions only
What it does
Comprehensive manuscript review with three modes: single-pass (default), --adversarial critic-fixer loop, and --peer [journal] simulated peer-review pipeline (editor + 2 dispositioned referees + editorial decision, calibrated to a target journal). R&R continuation via --peer --r2/--r3; hostile-editor stress test via --peer --stress; reviewer-disposition variance reporting via --peer --variance N. Auto-invokes /review-r + /audit-reproducibility on referenced scripts unless --no-cross-artifact.
Manuscript Review
Produce a thorough, constructive review of an academic manuscript, the kind of report a top-journal referee would write.
Which review skill do I want?
/review-paper(this skill), single comprehensive report, optional--adversarialcritic-fixer loop, or--peer <journal>simulated peer-review pipeline. Best for most drafts./seven-pass-review, seven independent lenses in parallel (abstract, intro, methods, results, robustness, prose, citations) then synthesized. Heavier (7× token cost). Best for submission-ready drafts or R&R stage where you need maximum coverage./respond-to-referees, if you already have referee comments and need a response document, not another review./slide-excellence, for lecture slides, not papers.
Input: $ARGUMENTS, path to a paper (.tex, .pdf, or .qmd), or a filename in master_supporting_docs/. Optional flags:
--adversarial, critic-fixer loop until dry (2 consecutive dry rounds; fallback cap 5).--peer <JOURNAL>, simulated peer review pipeline calibrated to<JOURNAL>(see.claude/references/journal-profiles.mdfor available short names).--r2/--r3, R&R continuation mode (requires--peer). Reloads prior round, classifies concerns Resolved / Partial / Not addressed.--stress, hostile-editor stress test (requires--peer). Forces SKEPTIC dispositions, doubles critical peeves.--variance(followed by integer N, default 3), reviewer-disposition variance mode (requires--peer). Runs N referees with independently sampled dispositions from the 6-way taxonomy. Editor aggregates into a decision distribution, not a point estimate. Mutually exclusive with--stressand--r2/--r3.--no-novelty-check, skip editor's WebSearch novelty probe (default is ON).--no-cross-artifact, skip auto-invocation of/review-r+/audit-reproducibilityon referenced scripts.
